It isn't specific to school. Also, it's obvious even with a uniform which children come from poorer homes. It's difficult to hide the fact that you only have one shirt and have to wear it all the time. And what of the alleged connection between results and uniform? Back in , the Conservatives pointed out that only one of the top-performing state schools was non-uniform.
Yet such statistics work the other way round, too. One man who has spent years studying such statistics is American academic David Brunsma. A sociology professor at Missouri-Colombia University, he became entangled with uniform following Bill Clinton's suggestion that schools consider uniforms as a way of controlling youth gang culture. Brunsma, who says he was "utterly flabbergasted" at such "superficial glossing over of complex social, democratic, cultural, material and political issues", embarked on some serious research.
After eight years, Brunsma concluded that: Uniforms do not make our schools better. So why the seemingly unstoppable rise of the blazer and tie? Such ideas are rarely debated in the UK. In the US, where uniform is spreading, its introduction is often fought on freedom of expression grounds. In Europe, uniform is relatively rare. Yet here in the UK, it goes largely unremarked that the increasing popularity of blazer and tie uniforms over the last 30 years has coincided with increasing social inequality.
The most serious recent investigation into what children wear to school was by the Office of Fair Trading — and that was into price. For Mason and Baker the absence of uniform brings a daily benefit, liberating them from having to nit-pick about pupils' clothing. As if to prove his point, another secondary head — also called Dave Baker — has been drawn into some unfortunate conversations about uniform recently, specifically about Miss Sexy trousers.
The tight-fitting trousers had become popular with girls at Bradley Stoke community school, Bristol. Girls who turned up in the Miss Sexy brand were told to change into them, a policy which some objected to as unhygienic. Overall, it appears that the judicial system allows schools to be restrictive when it comes to freedom of expression for the sake of creating a safe and productive learning environment.
Dress Codes and Uniforms. This is another good article by McCarthy giving examples of how the courts have treated school uniforms. Is It Right for Your School? A review of related literature is provided along with results of the opinions obtained from seventh- and eighth-grade middle school students attending a public school in Nevada that had recently initiated a school uniform policy. Improvements in discipline data and school police data were also examined.
Results highlighted the perceived benefits i. Few significant differences were found. This is a doctoral dissertation that can be located for free on the Web at: After accounting for race and students with disabilities status, School A with uniforms had significantly better attendance and somewhat fewer minor behavior infractions, but trended lower in standardized math scores and more intermediate and major behavioral infractions than School B without uniforms.
These findings failed to demonstrate an unambiguous advantage of school uniforms , consistent with the mixed results across reports in the published literature. Implications and suggestions for further research are detailed. Phi Delta Kappan, vol. In this March journal article, Angela gives her perspectives about school uniforms from her British experience with school uniforms. Angela believes that school uniforms can "create a more respectful atmosphere for learning and ease the burden on parents.
The author touches on the fact that school uniforms may not be a solution for all schools. She touches on a subject that is not seen in a lot of the literature, but is something to consider when she writes that we have to be careful about "creating a culture where parents think that a public school where children wear uniforms is an unsafe place to send their child.
Bomba, and Patsy A. This is a journal article with some statistics. Although the main focus of this scholarly journal article covers the attitudes of parents on school uniforms, this article does provide information on some of the common issues involving school uniforms.
The majority of views by the parents are positive for school uniforms. This is an older magazine article, but it does have some nice pro and con tidbits of information that can help support each side. School uniforms can "eliminate the baggy gang-inspired look that makes it easy for students to smuggle in weapons, drugs and other banned items. Another interesting issue with school uniforms is that some teachers believe that by allowing students to dress the way they want "gives teachers insights into what's happening with individual students.
If we see a big change in the way a student dresses, that sends up a signal and tells us we need to address the person. Pilling, in which the plaintiff Mary Frudden, a mother of third-grade and fifth-grade children, alleged that the mandatory school uniform policy instituted by the Roy Comm Elementary School in Reno, Nevada violated the children's First Amendment freedom of expression. Several questions related to this case are also discussed.
In making such decisions, the usual professional procedures apply, such as a. As a legal matter, the key is keeping the policy reasonably clear and content-neutral, with special cautions regarding any written or particular messages on the required uniform, and the wording and application of any exemptions or exceptions. Individual and social child development includes the idea of self-concept and self-esteem.
During middle childhood, children start evaluating themselves in comparison to others. It could be argued that school uniforms can reduce the stress between the haves and the have nots. School uniforms and dress codes may allow a more friendly environment with peer cooperation. Boivin, Michel, and Guy Begin. A possible introduction with thesis statement for a "con" paper on school uniforms might go something like this: However, school uniforms are not the solution to many of the issues that schools face.
A school uniform policy does not have a significant influence on producing a safe learning environment and helping students achieve. The haves and the have-nots will not be fooled by school uniforms; creativity and self-image suffers; gang members will continue to display gang-like behavior; uniforms are not cheap; and studies show that school uniforms are not a direct connection to achievement.
The following sentence after the thesis statement: Here is a possible outline for the CON paper about school uniforms: This is a major and significant CON research study. This article can be found on the Internet at:.
A Qualitative Analysis of Aims and Accomplishments. For example, parents and school officials believe that school uniforms eliminate competition, but several students felt this way:.
This January journal article is a little old, but gives a lot of very good pro AND con information about school uniforms. This article does a very good job of explaining the legal issues of school uniforms. Both sides have won in the courts over this issue and McCarthy gives examples.
It is a magazine article. It tackles methodological challenges through the use of a value-added functional form and the use of multiple data sets. The results do not suggest any significant association between school uniform policies and achievement. The Journal of Educational Research , , Vol. Proponents of such reform measures emphasize the benefits of student uniforms on specific behavioral and academic outcomes.
Tenth-grade data from The National Educational Longitudinal Study of was used to test empirically the claims made by uniform advocates. The findings indicate that student uniforms have no direct effect on substance use, behavioral problems, or attendance. Contrary to current discourse, the authors found a negative effect of uniforms on student academic achievement.
Uniform policies may indirectly affect school environment and student outcomes by providing a visible and public symbol of commitment to school improvement and reform. Rockquemore that claims that uniforms correlate negatively with academic achievement, but data presented in this article actually show positive correlation between uniforms and achievement for the total sample, and for all but 1 school sector.
Examination of structure of argument reveals that the erroneous claim results from misleading use of sector analysis. The two articles are contrasted in this study. The effect of new communication technology in amplifying political uses of academic research is discussed. Education and Urban Society , , Vol. The instruments used in the study included a questionnaire on gang presence and identity, the National Association of School Principals Comprehensive Assessment of School Environments, and the Harter Self-Perception Profile for Children.
Participants consisted of urban public middle school students and 83 teachers. Findings indicate that, although perceptions did not vary for students across uniform policy, teachers from schools with uniform policies perceived lower levels of gang presence.
English 10 Enriched 10 February Against the Idea of School Uniforms All around the United States more and more schools and switching to the idea of school uniforms.
Those Disgusting School Uniforms-- an anti-school uniform article that they go against our basic rights and there is not adequate research to support their use. Boy's Kilt Stirs Dress Code Debate -- an article explaining the case of a high school boy who was told to put on pants when he wore a kilt to his high school dance.
College of Education researchers conduct study on impacts of school uniforms Research on school uniforms is minimal, especially research on students' opinions about uniforms, and the use of student uniforms is a growing conversation across the country. there were many responses against wearing school uniforms, but a substantial number. An Argument Against School Uniforms I am a 10th grade student who also disagrees with the decision of making kids were school uniforms. I agree with possession of school uniforms takes away a.
Against School Dress Codes and Uniforms Essays - The Debate Between School Dress Codes and Uniforms The debate over school uniforms and dress codes has been going on for years and is still widely debated and talked about in the education system. As local governments continue debating the merits of public school uniforms, journalists can use these research studies to fact-check claims. As local governments continue debating the merits of public school uniforms, journalists can use these research studies to fact-check claims. Some employers discriminate against applicants with longer.